Home / Forums / News/Current Events / Pokémon Organized Play Policy Change - No Foreign ...
Thread Posts
06 Apr 2009 01:34 PM
ForumBot Automated Bots
Joined: 18 Jun 2007
Posts: 8060
logoThe official Pokemon TCG website has posted a policy change that affects players that use cards from other countries. Only cards that match the language of your country will be allowed to be use in premier events. The policy change goes into effect September 1, 2009. Below is the press release from the official site.

Over the course of several seasons, Pokémon Organized Play has noticed a sharp increase in the use of foreign-language cards in markets where those languages are not commonly understood by the player base. While we recognize that the Pokémon Trading Card Game is an international game, the unfortunate side effect of this increase is that it has added a layer of complexity to an already complex tournament setting at Premier Events. In cases where the majority of players and event staff are not fluent in these other languages, the pace of games has slowed due to translation issues, even with the use of the Card Dex or local-language reference cards.

Starting with the 2009–2010 tournament season, which begins September 1, 2009, Pokémon Organized Play will restrict the use of foreign-language cards at Premier Events, based on where those events take place. The Pokémon Trading Card Game is currently printed in English, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Portuguese, and Spanish. As English-language cards are distributed in the vast majority of markets worldwide, and more cards are printed in English than in any other language, English cards are legal for Premier Events in every market.

In Special Premier Events that encompass multiple countries, the Last Chance Qualifier, and the World Championships, players are permitted to use cards in any language listed for their home market during these events, regardless of where the event is held. Players from markets where a language is not listed under their country of residence are not permitted to use those cards. For example, a Canadian player may use English or French cards in the World Championships, but may not use German, Italian, Japanese, Portuguese, or Spanish cards.

This new rule will not affect the legality of foreign-language cards at non-Premier Events and Leagues.

Source: http://www.go-pokemon.com/op/news/articles/51.html
06 Apr 2009 04:19 PM
Joined: 25 Aug 2008
Posts: 28
User Avatar
I was surprised they\'re JUST making this rule.

I always thought it was already not allowed to use non-English cards in English tournaments.
06 Apr 2009 04:28 PM
Sunain Administrator
Joined: 18 Jun 2007
Posts: 1190
User Avatar
I\'m not sure what to think about this change. While I can understand that people aren\'t going to know all the other languages that the cards are available in, they are the same. The press release says that reference cards were being used but wasn\'t working. I figure if you\'re actually going to these events, you know what most cards are anyhow.
06 Apr 2009 04:53 PM
Joined: 25 Aug 2008
Posts: 28
User Avatar
The problem is, you can\'t exactly expect everyone to play fairly.

Plus there\'s chances of mistranslations, the fact alot of rules depend on wording which would be quite different, and of course people using cards that aren\'t out in their country yet. For example, if a card says \"Evolves from Piloswine\", you could argue that someone with an \"Inomu\" card coult not evolve it into a Mamoswine. It\'s the same Pokemon, but technically that would not be considered the same Pokemon.

Or, atleast that\'s how I see it.
13 Apr 2009 01:46 AM
inu-liger Administrator
Joined: 23 Jun 2007
Posts: 13
User Avatar
Very good points, Habunake. I also thought that unfair play would (or SHOULD) have been obvious from the start, despite other players with good intentions.

If anything, I think multi-language use should have never been allowed to begin with. I personally would not be surprised if that sort of play spawned arguments or even fights over unfair play, accusations about the accuracy of translations, etc. etc.